The material for this blogpost was originally for a reflective on The Catcher in the Rye, but I realized I connected with Esther (before the illness worsen)... It'll be a waste to let this train of thought crash anywhere else than your brain.
While watching Mr. Peabody & Sherman, I came across a line that reminded me of Holden's disdain with "Phoniness." Sherman says to his tormentor, who he later comes to adore, "Freud once said that the reason you dislike someone may be because you see a bit of yourself in them."
Maybe Holden dislikes "phoniness" because he can sense a bit of it growing within himself? But first, what is phoniness? The definition is never explicitly stated but it seems to have to do with a "person's pureness" or the level at which they are affected by the world--how caught up they are with social constructions.
Quick example: DB at first wrote neat stories about the weirdest things. But once he went to Hollywood, he started writing about things he could make movies out of, mild things that he knew other people will like. I'm assuming that that's what made him a prostitute in Holden's eyes: DB letting the world (or entertainment companies) use him and his name to rake in more cash.
Since Holden's too busy reflecting and analyzing other people's lives, he never gets a chance to sit down and look at himself, and how he's letting the world run him. He ends up where he does because he allows the world affect him; he let the phoniness drag him down. I mean I don't blame him; it's depressing as hell when everyone's a sheep. At the same time, he didn't mind getting beaten up by Maurice to prove a point--Maurice is a thief (as we said in class). So why can't he suffer through this phase and come out a writer so he can share his pain with the world? (As Antolini suggest and I agree). But Holden gets a headache so couldn't focus on the one thing that could "solve" or at least alleviate the phoniness issue.
Keeping in mind my interpretation of phoniness, I say Holden is the phoniest guy there is. Here he is spewing all this criticism about the world and what's wrong with it, but fails to act on it. Instead, he does stupid little things to give the illusion of making a difference. What's the difference between him and every other guy on the street then? Maybe he dislikes phoniness to that extent because he sees himself submerged it in and knows he can never forgive himself.
Or maybe, he's using the excuse that there's so many things wrong with the world to avoid looking at himself. It's not a new idea. We all use the excuse that the teacher did something wrong so we can't do our homework. We don't actually care that we can't do our homework, or that the teacher did something wrong. We just care that we don't want to admit we're lazy, or that we're confused.
I agree that Holden could say he doesn't like phonies because he is one, but I think it's a little deeper than that. At one point Holden tells us that he's a pathological liar, and lies all the time without really meaning to. This might be one trait he really doesn't like about himself, and that's why he is so obsessed with calling out the phonies.
ReplyDeleteThis generally makes sense to me. Whenever readers want to criticize Holden for not living up to his own standards, I want to say, You think he doesn't know that already? For all his confidence and swagger, I see a good deal of self-loathing between the lines in Holden's narrative. He's very much aware of his own incipient "phoniness," and it bothers him a lot. DB is a scary precedent for him, as he sees how an artist with integrity can be "corrupted."
ReplyDelete