There's something in the way that Holden refers to you, confides in you, treats you like his best friend that makes this reading experience different.
He's direct. He's sarcastic. He's funny. He's real. It's great.
It's great, until reality hits.
The moment this figurative "reality" hits you, as the reader, is when you finally see Holden at his "own school". This is when realize the subtle things Holden does to make everyone seem imperfect and he's the most tolerable imperfect person there.
Prior to this taste of reality, Holden is this really cool guy you've come to befriend. He goes to a different school, but he tells you the latest gossip. The more you talk to him, the more caught up in his prose you get, until you think he's this really cool guy in this really lame school.
There were many indications of his borderline phoniness that were ignored. For example, the way he sets up the introduction of Mr.Spencer. Spencer seems this non respectable figure that keeps yapping at Holden, who knows what he's doing. You'd almost feel like Holden is a victim of chronic nagging. Then with Ackley; he makes Ackley out to be this insufferable annoyance that doesn't understand social cues. It might be true, but then Holden goes and does the same thing and block's Stradlater's light. (cough. *Hypocrite.* cough.) With Stradlater too, Holden makes him out to be this narcissistic violent womanizer. To some extent, it's probably true. But Holden fails to negatively describe any of that stuff until Jane comes in. And Jane; he sets her on this pedestal and defends her the whole time he was at the hotel:but Jane's not that type of girl. You know. And all that stuff. But if she's really all this stuff, and he admires her so much, why not see her? He's running away from the realization that maybe, she wasn't playing checkers in the car with Stradlater.
He's definitely a biased narrator who wants to keep his reputation in the eyes of the reader. I think that's why he has to explain frequently; almost to justify his actions or set up the situation in his favor.
On some level, I can understand. He wants to show off, present himself in the best light. That's ok, but when you have that realization that this moment isn't what he's pulling you to believe with his description, you question the friendship and whether he's fit to narrate. Should I trust what he's saying? Is he actually misunderstood or someone who overthinks things about other people and doesn't take them seriously? Because the latter is kind of offensive. And I don't enjoy the company of offensive people.
I like that it's so subjective. It seems realistic. In your day to day life you never experience anything objectively. You can always read someone wrong or mishear or remember a little wrong; emotions will cloud your judgement. And we'd be making assumptions and what not anyway while reading, Holden just does it for us so that everyone reading the book will have a more consistent experience. I think it's fun to be inside his head and feel his emotions and the complicated, sort of fickle opinions of other people that he forms. And, actually, this might just be Holden's charm working its magic, but I trust him. He doesn't seem to be hiding his humiliation from us. He might be warping events to make him look right, but it's possible that people just naturally do this, and he thinks he's telling us his version straight. I agree he can be a little offensive, but he does try to see the good in people (or at least feel sorry for them).
ReplyDelete