Wednesday, May 6, 2015

"Breach of Protocol"

Up until recently, I was in charge of my sisters. This doesn't really mean much in the everyday sense, but once in a while, I would get to decide what to do with my Saturdays. 

For the past 5 years, I've been involved in a New Year's Show. For the past 3 years, so has my sister. She had voiced that she didn't want to many time, but I dismissed it because she liked to complain. However this year, she stayed firmed in her decision in not participating in the show. [She even pulled the "who asked you to plan what I do?" card. Tsk. Tsk.] This was a breach of protocol. 

We've always had a way of doing things, and no matter how much someone complained about it, we would suck it up if one of us wanted to do it. That was it. However, things are changing. My 15 year old sister is beginning to deviate in ways I've only seen from other people. She's learning all these things--like "The Whip"--that I wouldn't have been able to absorb when I was her age. 

I was reminded of this dynamic because of Benji and Reggie's situation on page 24 (in the hardback). Specifically in the scene when Benji asks Reggie where his bike is, and he replies that he's going to walk.  

The line that followed the scene is "It was the last time we'd start the summer that." (24). 

What does this mean? Is this the beginning of where the paths diverge? It scares me because no matter how annoying they get, I don't want them to be strangers. I don't want them to become people whose actions I don't understand, because I'm suppose to know them. 

Benji understands because even though he says he's going to leave Reggie, he recognizes and is unafraid to point out that he "didn't leave him" (24). It's like a promise the older sibling makes to the younger one, whether the younger sibling recognizes it or not. 

Saturday, May 2, 2015

That One Summer They'll Make a Movie About

I believe that summers are a vital part of growing up. Not actual summer, but the concept of stepping away from your everyday routine for something else. That separation from routine is what evokes change.

Everyday, you wake up at 640 to get ready for school Then you have 8 hours to get cultured. The last [24 minus duration of mandatory activities] hours to sleep. It is precisely because of that rigidity that change cannot occur. How could it when your environment is constant?


That's where summer comes in. Summer puts you in a totally different environment, so at first you struggle to handle the freedom like a fish on land. Then you develop your land legs, and call people up to hang out. Then you go and do stupid things.

For Benji, that's what may happen. Not because he willed change to happen but because it just will. He's being around different types of people than the ones in his private school, getting exposed to different ideas, and having forced to face the duality of his identity; things are bounded to change by the end of summer. Also, he writes a book about this summer and is constantly making references to "but I didn't know it then" etc.

I've always wondered though, why high school? Or the summer before senior year? Are those, just by some measure, the pivotal time in everyone's life?

Tuesday, April 21, 2015

Recognition

I've noticed that one of the key component of "growing up" or at least progressing in the coming of age process is being disillusioned. Disillusioned about a certain person, about how the world "really" works, etc.

[Their concerns are greatly simplified and diluted by my memory ]:
Holden: Everyone who had "grown up" were concerned with superficial things--> phonies.
Esther: the gender role
Ruth:... I'm not sure... I mean she never hoped for a normal life or had any hopes....
Jason: that the adult world is really just a glorified middle school hierarchy.
Stephen: his father, and maybe something else...

There's something that changes in their mindset that allows them--the protagonists--to pick up and realize the meaning behind the small things. I think at this age, or whenever they get disillusioned they start questioning authority as well... Regardless, that change in perception allows our characters to look at certain people different and maybe even reevaluate some beliefs.

I know that frequently this period does not last, and one somewhat continues to assimilate into society or some group that functions alongside the mainstream culture. But this part I don't know yet because I'm not middle aged.


For Jason, fresh blood to keep the revolution alive, he recognizes that his dad shouldn't admit "defeat" to Mr.Salt, because obviously Mr. Salt is wrong and trying to exert dominance over his dad. As he starts to see the reflection between his dad's dynamic at work with his at school, I hope he starts to see those kids aren't worth looking up to.

I'm afraid though because when you're a grown up, "things aren't that easy." There are other things that come into play. I mean even as a child. Yeah Jason can recognize that Wilcox and his posse are hallowed figures of authority, but if they beat him up.... Similar to his dad. His dad can stand up to Mr. Salt but, then he won't have a job. And for most people, a well and able man not having a job might mean that he failed as a "man," or at least in Helena's eyes. Both of they can "choose to reject the system" but what does that even mean?

I think the best you can do is just recognize there's something wrong. Then what? I don't know. I haven't gotten there.


Tuesday, March 31, 2015

Whose Abandonment Issues?

From class discussion, I felt like there's a lot of resent towards Lucille for ditching Ruth. 

The problem with that would be that that implies Lucille is in a better place and didn't take her sister along with her. 

Lucille isn't necessarily in a better place, and Ruth isn't necessarily in a bad place. Both girls seem content with themselves and their lifestyle. They both care for each other--as seen when Lucille shows up worried about where Ruth's been all day, and Ruth's caution towards not embarrassing Lucille in front of her friends in chpt 8--they just do it from afar. 

Yes yes, the people you meet and your relationship with them are transient, but their effect on you doesn't have to be. I'm fairly sure this was mentioned once somewhere. Ruth doesn't blame Lucille, so we're not in a place to either. 

Sometimes, I feel that because Ruth sometimes has the emotional disconnect we try extra hard to fill the gaps for her. We, the readers, have a need to get angry at all the people doing her an injustice.  Maybe that's why there's a strong reaction to Lucille, or Sylvie or Helen, saying that someone abandoned someone else, etc. 

Lucille is justifying her mother's suicide in a way that she can tell other people about it, and she won't feel embarrassed about it. A fear of abandonment may come with that explanation. Ruth is dealing it with it Ruth's way, which I'm a bit lost on. The statement of abandoner or abandonment, Ruth doesn't have much thought about it; she seems to just say it matter of fact. The sense of abandonment might actually stem from the reader as it's the most logical emotion to conclude with. Those feelings may very well not be what Ruth is feeling about her mother, or the people who left her. 




Thursday, March 26, 2015

Esther trapped in Yellow Wallpaper

I can't help but approach this book as a historian--this book is a perfect exaggerated example of the stifling gender roles that drove women insane (not clinically insane.)

In the 1950s, after women were being moved back to domestic role by the return of male workers, many felt a lingering desire for more now that they've tasted equality.

Not may voiced their opinion of this because it seemed like a requirement for being a woman is enjoying your housework. There also wasn't really a place for women to be heard; magazines only addressed socially acceptable issues that their male counterpart editors allowed. Or their ideas are dismissed before it leaves the house by their husbands, father, etc.

Much like when Esther says that she will not marry, Buddy says she's crazy. He doesn't hesitate brushing off her aspiration as a joke. It's really not his fault society doesn't take women seriously.
Esther is also upset at her limited options for the future, despite her hard work. Women really couldn't be anything other than the options Esther's mother gave her. It's not her mother's fault that that's all she's ever known, and could teach her daughter.

While Esther is able to justified her frustration with a person doing her wrong, other women couldn't. They just had to suffer it out, thinking that whatever dissatisfaction they felt with their life is wrong.
I didn't really mean to lead to this as a conclusion, but in some ways, Esther has it better than other women. At least with Esther she found a way out. She found a way out of the mental hospital (society's expectations). At least she could "transform" and kind of deal with the cards she's dealt now that someone has addressed her frustration.

Friday, February 27, 2015

The Phoniest of Phonies

The material for this blogpost was originally for a reflective on The Catcher in the Rye, but I realized I connected with Esther (before the illness worsen)... It'll be a waste to let this train of thought crash anywhere else than your brain.

While watching Mr. Peabody & Sherman, I came across a line that reminded me of Holden's disdain with "Phoniness." Sherman says to his tormentor, who he later comes to adore, "Freud once said that the reason you dislike someone may be because you see a bit of yourself in them."

Maybe Holden dislikes "phoniness" because he can sense a bit of it growing within himself? But first, what is phoniness? The definition is never explicitly stated but it seems to have to do with a "person's pureness" or the level at which they are affected by the world--how caught up they are with social constructions.

Quick example: DB at first wrote neat stories about the weirdest things. But once he went to Hollywood, he started writing about things he could make movies out of, mild things that he knew other people will like. I'm assuming that that's what made him a prostitute in Holden's eyes: DB  letting the world (or entertainment companies) use him and his name to rake in more cash.

Since Holden's too busy reflecting and analyzing other people's lives, he never gets a chance to sit down and look at himself, and how he's letting the world run him. He ends up where he does because he allows the world affect him; he let the phoniness drag him down. I mean I don't blame him; it's depressing as hell when everyone's a sheep. At the same time, he didn't mind getting beaten up by Maurice to prove a point--Maurice is a thief (as we said in class). So why can't he suffer through this phase and come out a writer so he can share his pain with the world? (As Antolini suggest and I agree). But Holden gets a headache so couldn't focus on the one thing that could "solve" or at least alleviate the phoniness issue.

Keeping in mind my interpretation of phoniness, I say Holden is the phoniest guy there is. Here he is spewing all this criticism about the world and what's wrong with it, but fails to act on it. Instead, he does stupid little things to give the illusion of making a difference. What's the difference between him and every other guy on the street then? Maybe he dislikes phoniness to that extent because he sees himself submerged it in and knows he can never forgive himself.

Or maybe, he's using the excuse that there's so many things wrong with the world to avoid looking at himself. It's not a new idea. We all use the excuse that the teacher did something wrong so we can't do our homework. We don't actually care that we can't do our homework, or that the teacher did something wrong. We just care that we don't want to admit we're lazy, or that we're confused.



Tuesday, February 10, 2015

A Remnant Of Stephen

I think somewhere along the tedious journey with Stephen, I've come to like him, because I keep seeing him in Holden.

At the start of the novel both protagonists, Stephen and Holden, were easily relatable. Stephen fear adults and the fearsome sermons. Holden dislikes phony people, and is sarcastic. (Among other things.)

As the novel progressed, however, I found myself distancing myself from them, cringing at their downward spiral. The ideas that they worship, I guess, began to dominate their lives, engulfing every possible sympathetic characteristic. Stephen becomes almost obsessed with condemnation; Holden  painstakingly tries to find some sort of authenticity that the world hasn't eroded. Near the end of the novel, I could no longer make excuses for them.

Along with the idea that they are the extremes of their beliefs, they also have no tolerance, no balance. The ideas that once drew me to them, have become the reason that I distanced myself.  Stephen couldn't suck it up for a moment and do his Easter duties to make his mother happy. Holden couldn't stand the idea of phoniness to the extent that he rather throw away his future to separate himself from it. I mean, suck it up! There should be a balance of personal beliefs and knowing your niche in the world. I'm not saying you should compromise your morals. I'm saying you can live the way you want to without being so satanic and abusive.

Holden and Stephen were not only the main characters of their respective novels, but of their lives. (Yes, yes, it's quite obvious everyone functions on their own plane. These two however take it to a whole another level.) Stephen admits (indirectly) that he's the character in a novel. Holden does it more subtly through the way he describes his interactions with other people. Holden talks at people, and manipulates the way the reader sees them. He does so with Spencer and Phoebe; he twists their image into something that will go along with this creative vision of them. He is characterizing them I think, since they're no longer complex people; just one dimensional figures that stabilizes or depresses him, moves the story along for him.

My concluding piece is not actually that strong but, oh well. I get the vibe that they both fear the dull abyss that is the rest of your grown up lives. Holden and Stephen seem to have this destined future picked by their surroundings (i.e the type of schools they go to). Holden doesn't want to become a lawyer--the subject that is often the butt of greed and selfishness jokes in my world--while Stephen doesn't want to become a priest of God. In fact, I would even say that this pressure becomes the (or one of) source of their turmoil. They try hard to stray from their paths. With Stephen though, although a bit more overdramatic and annoying, he really will do what he sets out to do. Holden just seems immature for disregarding the consequences.

I'm not sure if the connection is a strong or weak-bad-weather-day connection. Either way, it's there. Maybe it's there in all coming of age novels...

Wednesday, February 4, 2015

As Holden's BFF

There's something in the way that Holden refers to you, confides in you, treats you like his best friend that makes this reading experience different.

He's direct. He's sarcastic. He's funny. He's real. It's great.

It's great, until reality hits.

The moment this figurative "reality" hits you, as the reader, is when you finally see Holden at his "own school". This is when realize the subtle things Holden does to make everyone seem imperfect and he's the most tolerable imperfect person there.

Prior to this taste of reality, Holden is this really cool guy you've come to befriend. He goes to a different school, but he tells you the latest gossip. The more you talk to him, the more caught up in his prose you get, until you think he's this really cool guy in this really lame school.

There were many indications of his borderline phoniness that were ignored. For example, the way he sets up the introduction of Mr.Spencer. Spencer seems this non respectable figure that keeps yapping at Holden, who knows what he's doing. You'd almost feel like Holden is a victim of chronic nagging. Then with Ackley; he makes Ackley out to be this insufferable annoyance that doesn't understand social cues. It might be true, but then Holden goes and does the same thing and block's Stradlater's light. (cough. *Hypocrite.* cough.) With Stradlater too, Holden makes him out to be this narcissistic violent womanizer. To some extent, it's probably true. But Holden fails to negatively describe any of that stuff until Jane comes in. And Jane; he sets her on this pedestal and defends her the whole time he was at the hotel:but Jane's not that type of girl. You know. And all that stuff. But if she's really all this stuff, and he admires her so much, why not see her? He's running away from the realization that maybe, she wasn't playing checkers in the car with Stradlater.

He's definitely a biased narrator who wants to keep his reputation in the eyes of the reader. I think that's why he has to explain frequently; almost to justify his actions or set up the situation in his favor.

On some level, I can understand. He wants to show off, present himself in the best light. That's ok, but when you have that realization that this moment isn't what he's pulling you to believe with his description, you question the friendship and whether he's fit to narrate. Should I trust what he's saying? Is he actually misunderstood or someone who overthinks things about other people and doesn't take them seriously? Because the latter is kind of offensive. And I don't enjoy the company of offensive people.

Tuesday, January 20, 2015

18 going on 13?

The Stephen we're dealing with in the reading, I assume, is close to my age. This means I should be able to connect, or at least understand what he's thinking. But I don't.

I did understand him at one point, but I'll acknowledge that the age with which I connected with the most is younger than where I should mentally be (If that makes sense). On occasion, if someone bumps into me, I too will imagine them turning around later to apologize and I will graciously accept their apology. So that people won't take notice of me, I will go on Facebook and like a few pictures to make it seem as though I would/could ever go on those late night parties. (I'm referring to when he pretends like he's playing rugby with the big boys, but has no idea and no intention of learning. He only does so to remain unnoticed.)

While I'm not repeating things in my head or feel as conflicted as Stephen as, I'm also not criticizing adults nor finding my father to be disgusting. So I'm not completely in touch with my 13(?) year old side, but I'm no where near my 18 year old side either.

It's also a little scary for me, because how do I get to the 18 year mentality? How old am I really? When do I get the courage to pursue the adventures I narrate for myself as Stephen does? Going with the theme of the class, I am in need of a "coming to age" summer or event. I am in no hurry though, considering what Stephen's dealing with. (Almost 3+ pages of him describing his inadequacy and soul never receiving redemption.)

Friday, January 9, 2015

Dashed Dreams

I once had a dream. As weird as it was, it was still my precious dreams. It was what kept me going; what kept me smiling; what kept me... a child? 

Although I don't remember when it wilted away (under erosion, stern parenting, laws), I know that at one point I wanted to marry an elephant. To my innocent mind, marriage symbolized devotion and love. I love elephants, and wanted to be with them always--didn't understand monogamy either--so why not tie the knot!

I had lots of "supporters*". They would "aw" and say "how cute", the whole sha-bam, causing me to think I was on the road to my happily-ever-after at the age of 5. But then my 6th birthday came. Everything changed. It was no longer acceptable to be married to elephants; to put money into my savings jar to go see my beloveds. My life started to revolve around school work and interacting with real people. I started to forget that dream, and my priorities changed. I was too "old" for this nonsense  said the tall people*. 

If I had known about the concept of coming of age at 10 years old, I would say that 6 was the beginning of my coming of age journey. I mean, from everything people said in class--your priorities changed, you give up on unrealistic dreams, you start to provide for yourself(I made my own lunch and grew my own carrots), you see yourself differently--that would seem most appropriate. 

Yet, it's not. As much as we say coming of age is arbitrary, many people would refuse to acknowledge my coming of age moment. But for me at 10 years old, it might have been. Are my observations not valid because to others I "was" a child? Did I not meet the age requirement, modeled after characters in coming of age novels, thus my conclusion cannot hold value? There's always going to be a scoff; a voice saying just wait till you're older, you'll see. 

Well I'm 18. I'm ready for that coming of age event that will change things. I still don't see anything. If anything, my life changed more when I was 6. 

[Disclaimer: marrying an elephant is illegal. my parents said so.]   
*condescending people