I think somewhere along the tedious journey with Stephen, I've come to like him, because I keep seeing him in Holden.
At the start of the novel both protagonists, Stephen and Holden, were easily relatable. Stephen fear adults and the fearsome sermons. Holden dislikes phony people, and is sarcastic. (Among other things.)
As the novel progressed, however, I found myself distancing myself from them, cringing at their downward spiral. The ideas that they worship, I guess, began to dominate their lives, engulfing every possible sympathetic characteristic. Stephen becomes almost obsessed with condemnation; Holden painstakingly tries to find some sort of authenticity that the world hasn't eroded. Near the end of the novel, I could no longer make excuses for them.
Along with the idea that they are the extremes of their beliefs, they also have no tolerance, no balance. The ideas that once drew me to them, have become the reason that I distanced myself. Stephen couldn't suck it up for a moment and do his Easter duties to make his mother happy. Holden couldn't stand the idea of phoniness to the extent that he rather throw away his future to separate himself from it. I mean, suck it up! There should be a balance of personal beliefs and knowing your niche in the world. I'm not saying you should compromise your morals. I'm saying you can live the way you want to without being so satanic and abusive.
Holden and Stephen were not only the main characters of their respective novels, but of their lives. (Yes, yes, it's quite obvious everyone functions on their own plane. These two however take it to a whole another level.) Stephen admits (indirectly) that he's the character in a novel. Holden does it more subtly through the way he describes his interactions with other people. Holden talks at people, and manipulates the way the reader sees them. He does so with Spencer and Phoebe; he twists their image into something that will go along with this creative vision of them. He is characterizing them I think, since they're no longer complex people; just one dimensional figures that stabilizes or depresses him, moves the story along for him.
My concluding piece is not actually that strong but, oh well. I get the vibe that they both fear the dull abyss that is the rest of your grown up lives. Holden and Stephen seem to have this destined future picked by their surroundings (i.e the type of schools they go to). Holden doesn't want to become a lawyer--the subject that is often the butt of greed and selfishness jokes in my world--while Stephen doesn't want to become a priest of God. In fact, I would even say that this pressure becomes the (or one of) source of their turmoil. They try hard to stray from their paths. With Stephen though, although a bit more overdramatic and annoying, he really will do what he sets out to do. Holden just seems immature for disregarding the consequences.
I'm not sure if the connection is a strong or weak-bad-weather-day connection. Either way, it's there. Maybe it's there in all coming of age novels...
It was interesting to read about how you reacted to each of the two protagonists. I had a similar experience reading Stephen's journey—the beginning of Joyce's novel depicted the awkwardness of growing up really accurately in my opinion, but as Stephen's path began taking more individualized turns, I found myself unable to fully understand and sympathize. Unlike you, though, the character of Holden Caulfield resonated really deeply with me all throughout; while I definitely wouldn't endorse every single one of his decisions, I feel like he and I are coming from a similar place, and there were actually lots of times throughout the book where I thought, wow, I've totally thought that exact thing before! I've totally felt that exact emotion before! I'm not sure if there's a point to this comment other than to share my own experiences reading these books—anyhow, I really enjoyed your take on these characters, especially since we have a really similar take on one of them and a totally different one on the other!
ReplyDeleteI see Stephen in Holden, too (if I tried to disagree on that point, my brain would argue otherwise; it needs five extra seconds to distinguish between the two names before I say either aloud). You bring up interesting points, and thinking about your statement that Holden tends to see certain people as one dimensional, I think Holden's lack of empathy is, to an extent, on par with Stephen's. Stephen has a strong sense of superiority, but Holden does, too (looking down on others for being phonies and liking movies must be some brand of arrogance). It's interesting that we're willing to forgive Holden for much more than we're willing to excuse Stephen; it makes me wonder what Portrait would be like if Stephen could narrate his story in typical Caulfield style.
ReplyDelete