Tuesday, March 31, 2015

Whose Abandonment Issues?

From class discussion, I felt like there's a lot of resent towards Lucille for ditching Ruth. 

The problem with that would be that that implies Lucille is in a better place and didn't take her sister along with her. 

Lucille isn't necessarily in a better place, and Ruth isn't necessarily in a bad place. Both girls seem content with themselves and their lifestyle. They both care for each other--as seen when Lucille shows up worried about where Ruth's been all day, and Ruth's caution towards not embarrassing Lucille in front of her friends in chpt 8--they just do it from afar. 

Yes yes, the people you meet and your relationship with them are transient, but their effect on you doesn't have to be. I'm fairly sure this was mentioned once somewhere. Ruth doesn't blame Lucille, so we're not in a place to either. 

Sometimes, I feel that because Ruth sometimes has the emotional disconnect we try extra hard to fill the gaps for her. We, the readers, have a need to get angry at all the people doing her an injustice.  Maybe that's why there's a strong reaction to Lucille, or Sylvie or Helen, saying that someone abandoned someone else, etc. 

Lucille is justifying her mother's suicide in a way that she can tell other people about it, and she won't feel embarrassed about it. A fear of abandonment may come with that explanation. Ruth is dealing it with it Ruth's way, which I'm a bit lost on. The statement of abandoner or abandonment, Ruth doesn't have much thought about it; she seems to just say it matter of fact. The sense of abandonment might actually stem from the reader as it's the most logical emotion to conclude with. Those feelings may very well not be what Ruth is feeling about her mother, or the people who left her. 




3 comments:

  1. Yes! Completely and totally agree! Lucille acts the way just about any teen would in her situation, and I harbor no resentment towards her for leaving. She did what was right for her, just as Ruth ends up doing. In fact I respect Lucille even more because of all the ways she really tries to reach out to her admittedly distant sister. I'm a little harsher to Ruth in my post...

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the question posed isn't necessarily if one lifestyle is better than the other but more along the lines of whether or not one is satisfied with their own life, and everyone has their own standards for defining their lives. Lucille can't possibly be happy living the way Ruth does and vice versa, I totally agree with your points. Because both feel that satisfaction (while we don't hear from Lucille I can assume she eventually finds the order she has been seeking) I think both have succeeded.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is an excellent question around which to contemplate the significance of point of view in shaping our apprehension of a narrative. As Ruth acknowledges, when it comes to their mother, she and Lucille see things differently, and tell different stories. Likewise, when she contemplates her night with Lucille on the lake, where she is having an intense, personal, incommunicable and even spiritual experience, she's aware "Lucille would tell it differently." It's an interesting effect of this novel, and how it successfully inverts our assumptions in so many ways, that we find Ruth's point of view easier to understand and sympathize with than Lucille's--when in fact Lucille occupies the much more familiar attitude toward society, home, etc.

    ReplyDelete