Tuesday, January 20, 2015

18 going on 13?

The Stephen we're dealing with in the reading, I assume, is close to my age. This means I should be able to connect, or at least understand what he's thinking. But I don't.

I did understand him at one point, but I'll acknowledge that the age with which I connected with the most is younger than where I should mentally be (If that makes sense). On occasion, if someone bumps into me, I too will imagine them turning around later to apologize and I will graciously accept their apology. So that people won't take notice of me, I will go on Facebook and like a few pictures to make it seem as though I would/could ever go on those late night parties. (I'm referring to when he pretends like he's playing rugby with the big boys, but has no idea and no intention of learning. He only does so to remain unnoticed.)

While I'm not repeating things in my head or feel as conflicted as Stephen as, I'm also not criticizing adults nor finding my father to be disgusting. So I'm not completely in touch with my 13(?) year old side, but I'm no where near my 18 year old side either.

It's also a little scary for me, because how do I get to the 18 year mentality? How old am I really? When do I get the courage to pursue the adventures I narrate for myself as Stephen does? Going with the theme of the class, I am in need of a "coming to age" summer or event. I am in no hurry though, considering what Stephen's dealing with. (Almost 3+ pages of him describing his inadequacy and soul never receiving redemption.)

4 comments:

  1. It makes sense that a reader--even one immersed in roughly the same stage of life as Stephen--would have some trouble relating to him and his experiences. It fits with his sense of himself as "different" from others; paradoxically, our deep access to his candid consciousness doesn't make him seem more "normal" and universally relateable but more idiosyncratic and strange. He *is* a rather strange dude, by his own admission. Maybe one quasi-"universal" insight that can be drawn here is that we're all strange in our own idiosyncratic ways? Your version of a novel like this would be totally different from Stephen's because his is a reflection of a highly idiosyncratic consciousness under construction.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also find it harder to relate with older Stephen--"painfully honest" is a phrase that comes to mind when I think of his narrative style. However, I believe that I'm forcing a lack of empathy because I see a bit of myself in him. I'm not as confident, proud, or ashamed as he is, but I think Stephen still embodies typically teenage traits. Those traits are inflated beyond recognition with brutal honesty (because these experiences are very vivid for Stephen, so we're dragged along with him), which makes them uglier than they normally would be. Any teen can relate to the things he does and experiences--emulating certain characters, feeling shame, feeling unique or special--but because these emotions are so exaggerated in his thoughts, we no longer feel comfortable identifying with him.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Stephen certainly seems much more human when he's younger, because Joyce didn't really have anything to criticize about his younger self when his younger self was 5. However, as Stephen becomes the Joyce that Joyce remembers, it would make sense that he would become more alienated, both because of Joyce's experiences in his past and because Joyce want's to make fun of his younger self. So maybe we aren't supposed to connect with Stephen?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't think it's easy for anyone to get in touch with Stephen. I feel like he constantly knows that he's talking to an audience, so he's speaking in a certain way to impress us. His overall demeanor is bizarre, making it extremely hard to sympathize. He also doesn't seem to tell us all the important things going on in his head. We listen to a lot of his weird musings and mumbles, but we also don't get to hear many of the types of significant thoughts that typical teenagers have. But as a child, he wasn't as good at articulating his thoughts, making it easier for us to know what he was really thinking rather than what he wants us to believe. (Or maybe I'm just not understanding this at all!) I definitely agree with you on relating to younger Stephen. His level of awkwardness is something that I think many can relate to.

    ReplyDelete